New Jersey Bakery Cakes & Cookies

Homemade Sweet Treats for Every Occasion

Calandra’s Bakery specializes in delicious, stunning and high quality cakes and cookies for special occasions and everyday dessert options. Not only are these scrumptious treats available in our three individual Calandra’s Bakeries, but they’re also sold at retail locations and supermarkets throughout New Jersey and the greater New York City area. While some of our cakes and cookies are prepared in a traditional and classic way, we also offer made-to-order cakes and custom cookies for the special occasions in our valued customers’ lives.

The cakes pictured are all available for in-store pickup anytime in both 5’’ and 7’’ sizes but can be made in up to a full sheet cake or even a custom tiered cake. Give us a call at least one week in advance and we’ll be able to customize your cake in both design and size!

Please note that tiered creations require a minimum of one week.

Our delicious cookies are handmade daily! Fill up a bag or box with your favorites, or have us prepare a cookie tray for an upcoming occasion. If you’re in the mood for a bigger treat, grab one of our jumbo varieties and indulge!

View a list of our products below or CLICK HERE for our full wholesale product catalog.


Cakes at Our NJ Bakeries

We take great pride in our cake baking and decorating, and have been offering a wide selection of cakes for many years. Our classic bakery cakes are available in both 5” and 7” sizes. However, they can also be turned into a full sheet cake or a custom tiered cake upon request. From rum cakes to chocolate shadow cakes, our desserts are perfect for a satisfying sweet treat after a family meal, and a great way to end a small celebration or gathering. These cakes are available for in-store pickup at any of our Calandra’s Bakery locations.

Looking for a unique, extravagant cake? At Calandra’s Bakery, we also create amazing specialty cakes for the milestones and memorable celebrations in your life. As one of the most experienced customized cake bakers and decorators in New Jersey, our trained pastry chefs make sure that the outcome is exactly as desired by our customers. This is so that our customer’s special day can be made complete, with a beautiful and delicious treat that friends and family can always remember. If you’d like to order a customized cake, please give us a call at least a week in advance so that we can accommodate your needs in a timely manner. Please note that tiered creations require a minimum of one week as well.

Carrot Cake

Carrot cake with cream cheese filling and icing with coconut shavings

Lemon Cake

Vanilla cake with lemon filling and buttercream icing with coconut shavings

Chocolate Fudge Cake

Chocolate cake with chocolate fudge filling and icing

Chocolate Mousse Cake

Chocolate cake with chocolate mousse filling and icing

Chocolate Strawberry Shortcake

Chocolate cake with strawberry preserve filling and whipped cream icing

Strawberry Shortcake

Vanilla cake with strawberry preserve filling and whipped cream icing

Cookies n Cream Cake

Chocolate cake with cookies and cream buttercream filling and icing

Vanilla Fudge Cake

Vanilla cake with chocolate fudge filling and icing

Strawberry Mousse Cake

Chocolate cake with raspberry mousse filling and icing

Chocolate Shadow Cake

Chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream filling and icing

Baked Alaska

Vanilla Cake with chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry gelato filling

Gelato Cake

Vanilla or chocolate cake with chocolate and vanilla gelato filling

Tiramisu Cake

Sponge cake soaked in coffee and liquor with powdered chocolate and mascarpone cheese, complete with ladyfinger cookies.

Chocolate Ice Cream Cake

Chocolate cake with chocolate gelato filling

Cannoli Cake

Vanilla cake with cannoli filling and icing with crushed cannoli shells

French Delight

Cheesecake and chocolate cake with chocolate mousse filling, topped with chocolate ganache

Spider Cake

Vanilla and chocolate cake with one layer of chocolate fudge and one layer of buttercream filling and buttercream icing

Cookies n Cream Cake

Chocolate cake with cookies and cream buttercream filling and icing

Blackout Cake

Chocolate cake with chocolate pudding filling and icing

Rum Cake

Italian sponge cake soaked in rum with custard and chocolate pudding filling and whipped cream icing

Brown Derby Cake

Chocolate cake with bananas, peaches, and strawberry filling with whipped cream icing

Red Velvet Cake

Red velvet cake with cream cheese icing and filling

Seven Layer Cake

Chocolate cake with seven layers of chocolate pudding filling and chocolate fudge icing. Also available in vanilla cake.

Checkerboard Cake

Chocolate and vanilla cake with chocolate fudge icing and filling

Cannoli Shell Cake

Jumbo traditional or chocolate-covered cannoli shell filled and decorated with mini cannolis.

Pies at Our NJ Bakeries

Apple Pie

Apple Crumb Pie with Raisins

Coconut Custard Pie

Cherry Crumb Pie (Also available in blueberry)

New York Style Cheesecake

Marble Cheesecake

Vanilla Cheesecake

Key Lime Pie

Boston Cream Pie

Cheesecake topped with fresh fruits

Fruit Tart

Ricotta Cheesecake

Pecan Pie

Cookies at Our NJ Bakeries

Timeless cookies that taste just like your grandmother used to make can be found at any of our Calandra’s Bakery locations. Linzer tarts, coconut macaroons, and even chocolate covered pretzels are just a few of the many goodies that we make by hand daily. We make it a priority to craft these cookies using reliable and delicious recipes, and always decorate them so that they look as exceptional as they taste.

Although these cookies come in a standard and normal size, we also offer jumbo varieties for those who are looking to really indulge their sweet tooth. We always provide boxes and bags for customers to fill up at our bakery locations. Our caring staff can also make a cookie platter with our fresh, homemade cookies if you have an upcoming party, celebration or special event, such as a birthday, graduation or your wedding.

Miniature Elephant Ears

Miniature Linzer Tarts

Jelly Sandwich Cookies

Guava Cookies

Miniature Black & White Cookies

Miniature Chocolate Chip & Chocolate Dipped Cookies

Pecan Bars

Black & White Cookies

Chocolate Chip & Chocolate Dipped Cookies

M&M Cookies

Chinese Cookies

Chocolate Almond Horseshoe

Cinnamon Sticks

Chocolate Cigars

Elephant Ears

Pecan Sandy Cookies

Linzer Tarts

Tricolor Cookies

Horseshoe Butter Cookie

Lemon Biscotti

Chocolate Dipped Sandwich Cookies

Coconut Macaroons

Miniature Pecan Sandy Cookies

Miniature M&M Cookies

Miniature Chinese Cookies

Sprinkled Butter Cookies

Chocolate Covered Coconut Macaroons

Pignoli Cookies

Rugelach Cookies

Available in chocolate, raspberry, and apricot

Chocolate Sandwich Cookies

Love Knots / Anisette Cookies

Biscotti Cookies

Hard Almond, Soft Hazelnut, Chocolate soft hazelnut

Chocolate Covered Pretzels

Contact Our NJ Bakery Locations About Our Cakes and Cookies

If you have an upcoming special occasion and need cookies or a cake – or if you’re inquiring about prices, ingredients or more details – please feel free to contact Calandra’s Bakery by filling out a form online.